Becky vs. Buttface: An Honest Comparison of the Two Butt-Skincare Brands

Buttface and Becky are the two direct butt-skincare brands you'll see compared most often. They've taken very different approaches to the same underlying skin biology. This is an honest breakdown of which is right for whom — from the people who make Becky.

The 30-second version

The philosophical difference

Buttface treats the butt like a face that needs facials. Their thesis is solid: butt skin is biologically distinct from the rest of the body, with more oil glands and friction exposure, so it deserves a multi-step routine. They built a cleanser + treatment + moisturizer system around it.

Becky takes a different bet: most people won't run a 3-step daily butt-skincare routine. They want one product that handles 80% of the problem in 2–3 minutes a week. The walnut shell physical exfoliation + active oils combo addresses the highest-leverage step (exfoliation) and the secondary moisturization in a single product.

Neither approach is wrong. They're targeting different psychologies.

The ingredient breakdown

How they exfoliate

Buttface uses chemical exfoliation — AHAs (alpha hydroxy acids like glycolic and lactic) and BHAs (salicylic acid) to dissolve dead skin and unclog follicles. Pro: very thorough, no mechanical action needed. Con: can be irritating to sensitive skin, photosensitizes, takes longer to feel results.

Becky uses physical exfoliation — finely milled walnut shell powder. Pro: immediate tactile smoothness, works on KP specifically (chemical acids alone struggle with keratin plugs), no photosensitization. Con: not appropriate same-day as shaving/waxing.

Honest verdict: chemical for dark spots and acne, physical for KP and immediate texture. Some people are best served by both, used on different days.

The active oils

Buttface includes caffeine, peptides, and niacinamide. Caffeine is mostly cosmetic effect (temporary tightening). Peptides have modest evidence for body skin. Niacinamide has strong evidence for tone and barrier function.

Becky uses rosehip seed oil (vitamin A precursors, evidence-backed for fading PIH), jojoba (moisture barrier), aloe (anti-inflammatory), and B5 (skin repair). The rosehip is the standout — it's one of the most-studied natural ingredients for hyperpigmentation.

What's NOT in either

Both brands are sulfate-free and paraben-free. Both avoid synthetic fragrances at scale. Neither tests on animals.

The price question

$95 vs. $20 isn't really comparable — you're buying different things.

Buttface $95 = full 3-step ritual (3 products), enough to last 2–3 months at daily use. Per-month cost: ~$30–45.

Becky $20 = one product, 2 oz, lasts 4–6 weeks at 2–3x weekly use. Per-month cost: ~$15–20.

If you're thinking per-month cost of an effective routine, Becky is ~$15–20 (add a $5–10 medicated body wash like PanOxyl and you're at $25–30 / month). Buttface is $30–45 / month.

Pick Becky if:

• You want one product to handle the routine
• Your concern is buttne, KP, ingrowns, or texture
• You have sensitive skin and want a gentler approach
• You prefer physical exfoliation
• You don't want to introduce 3 new products to your shower
• You want to test a brand for $20 before committing
• You like that 1% goes to Every Mother Counts

Pick Buttface if:

• You love multi-step skincare and would actually do it
• Your primary concern is dark spots / hyperpigmentation (their chemical exfoliation is well-suited)
• You want a daily-friendly chemical exfoliation routine
• The "facial for your butt" framing resonates with how you think about your routine
• You don't mind paying premium for the full system

The complementary use case

Some people use both, strategically:

• Becky 2x weekly (Mondays + Thursdays) for physical exfoliation and KP texture
• Buttface chemical treatment on alternate days for dark spots and clogged pores

This is genuinely effective for people with both KP and significant hyperpigmentation. The trade-off is cost (~$45/month combined) and shower-routine complexity.

The honest take

We're not going to tell you Buttface is bad — their thesis is right, their formulations are solid, and they helped establish the category. We will tell you that for most people, a $20 walnut + rosehip scrub used 2–3x weekly handles the same problems for less money and less commitment.

If you've never done butt skincare before, start with Becky. If after 6–8 weeks you feel like you want more (or want a daily-friendly chemical-exfoliation layer), add Buttface or a generic CeraVe SA wash. Working back from full-routine-out-of-the-gate is harder than working up.

FAQ

Are walnut and chemical exfoliation safe to combine?

Yes — on different days. Don't physically scrub and apply an acid the same day. Alternate.

Which is better for sensitive skin?

Becky, generally. Chemical exfoliation can trigger sensitivity in newer-to-skincare people. The walnut + B5 + aloe combo is gentler at the outset.

Which is better for dark skin tones?

Becky's gentler approach is generally safer for deeper skin tones, where chemical exfoliation can cause paradoxical hyperpigmentation if overused. If you do choose chemical exfoliation, start slow.

Will Buttface's routine work alongside the Becky scrub?

Yes — they're complementary. Becky for KP/physical-texture days, Buttface for chemical-exfoliation/tone days.

Can I just use a face cleanser + face moisturizer on my butt instead of either?

You can, but you'd be overspending dramatically. Face skincare is priced for face surface area + sensitivity. Butt skin tolerates more substantial exfoliation than face skin, so a dedicated butt product is more efficient (and cheaper).

The bottom line

Buttface and Becky both work — different philosophies, different price points, different formats. If you want a single effective product, choose Becky. If you love multi-step routines and have the budget, Buttface delivers the full system. Or use both.

Try Becky for $20 →

Read next: Becky vs Anese · The complete routine